Economic profitability of agroforestry in nitrate vulnerable zones in Catalonia (NE Spain)

  • Simone Blanc University of Torino, Dept. of Agricultural, Forest and Food Sciences (DISAFA), 10095 Grugliasco
  • Carles M. Gasol Research Park of the Autonomous University of Barcelona (PRUAB), Inèdit Innovació SL, Bellaterra (Cerdanyola del Vallès) 08193 Barcelona
  • Julia Martínez-Blanco Research Park of the Autonomous University of Barcelona (PRUAB), Inèdit Innovació SL, Bellaterra (Cerdanyola del Vallès) 08193 Barcelona
  • Pere Muñoz Institute of Agrifood Research and Technology (IRTA), Environmental Horticulture Program, Ctra. De Cabrils s/n 08348 Cabrils
  • Jaime Coello Forest Science and Technology Centre of Catalonia (CTFC), Solsona, 25280 Lleida
  • Pere Casals Forest Science and Technology Centre of Catalonia (CTFC), Solsona, 25280 Lleida
  • Angela Mosso University of Torino, Dept. of Agricultural, Forest and Food Sciences (DISAFA), 10095 Grugliasco
  • Filippo Brun University of Torino, Dept. of Agricultural, Forest and Food Sciences (DISAFA), 10095 Grugliasco
Keywords: silvoarable practices, alley cropping, riparian buffer strips, N- leaching, economic evaluation


The impact of agricultural practices and the excess application of nitrogen can negatively impact the environment and cause human health problems. In Spain, the liquid manure applied in areas of intensive agriculture is creating groundwater nitrate pollution problems. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the economic profitability of agroforestry practices in North East Spain. Therefore, it deals with an alternative land use that has attracted attention in recent years, considering its potential to reduce the negative impact of modern agriculture that combines concurrent forestry and agricultural production in the same area. Specifically, silvoarable practices, such as alley cropping (AC), edge row planting and riparian buffer (RB) strips were compared to conventional agricultural land use. Considering the current agricultural policy framework in Spain, which does not favour these practices, our results showed the economic profitability of alley-cropping practices in comparison to conventional barley production of 25 to 64 € ha-1 yr-1. However, AC systems presented negative results compared to the traditional wheat crop (-122 to -63 € ha-1 yr-1). The results for RB strips were strongly influenced by the high initial costs, both in irrigated and non-irrigated scenarios. Economic results were negative (between -137 and -85 € ha-1 yr-1) compared to the conventional crops, barley and corn. These figures could be greatly increased with a policy framework that promotes these practices based on the fundamental ecosystem services they provide. Moreover, these practices allow an economic diversification that could prove to be beneficial for the majority of farmers.


Download data is not yet available.


Andrianarisoa KS, Dufour L, Bienaime S, Zeller B, Dupraz C, 2016. The introduction of hybrid walnut trees (Juglans nigra x regia cv. NG23) into cropland reduces soil mineral N content in autumn in southern France. Agrofor Syst 90: 193-205.

Arauzo M, Valladolid M, 2013. Drainage and N-leaching in alluvial soils under agricultural land uses: Implications for the implementation of the EU Nitrates Directive. Agr Ecosyst Environ 179: 94-107.

Bayo J, Gomez-Lopez MD, Faz A, Caballero A, 2012. Environmental assessment of pig slurry management after local characterization and normalization. J Clean Prod 32: 227-235.

Bigeriego M, 2001. El sector ganadero y el medio ambiente en España. [The livestock sector and the environment in Spain]. IV Congreso Nacional de Suinicultura, Lisboa.

Blanc S, Accastello C, Girgenti V, Brun F, Mosso A, 2018a. Innovative strategies for the raspberry supply chain: An environmental and economic assessment. Quality - Access to Success 19: 139-142.

Blanc S, Brun F, Di Vita G, Mosso A, 2018b. Traditional beekeeping in rural areas: Profitability analysis and feasibility of pollination service. Quality - Access to Success 19: 72-79.

Blanc S, Accastello C, Bianchi E, Lingua F, Vacchiano G, Mosso A, Brun F, 2019. An integrated approach to assess carbon credit from improved forest management. J Sustain Forest 38 (1): 31-45.

Borin M, Bigon E, 2002. Abatement of NO3-N concentration in agricultural waters by narrow buffer strips. Environ Pollut 117: 165-168.

Breustedt G, Glauben T, 2007. Driving forces behind exiting from farming in Western Europe. J Agr Econ 58: 115-127.

Briggs S, 2012. Agroforestry: A new approach to increasing farm production. Nuffield Farming Scholarships Trust Report. Stratford Upon Avon, UK. NFU Mutual Charitable Trust. 82 pp.

Buchholz T, Volk T, 2013. Profitability of Willow biomass crops affected by incentive programs. Bioenerg Res 6: 53-64.

Buckley C, Hynes S, Mechan S, 2012. Supply of an ecosystem service-farmers' willingness to adopt riparian buffer zones in agricultural catchments. Environ Sci Policy 24: 101-109.

Burgess PJ, Incoll, LD, Corry DT, Beaton A, Hart BJ, 2005. Poplar (Populus spp) growth and crop yields in a silvoarable experiment at three lowland sites in England. Agroforest Syst 63: 157-169.

Børgesen CD, Vinther FP, 2012. The effect of measures implemented from 2003 to 2007 to reduce nitrogen leaching from agricultural land in Denmark. 17th Nitrogen Workshop 2012.

Cambria D, Pierangeli D, 2012. Application of a life cycle assessment to walnut tree (Juglans regia L.) high quality wood production: a case study in southern Italy. J Clean Prod 23: 37-46.

Capodaglio AG, Callegari A, Lopez MV, 2016. European framework for the diffusion of biogas uses: Emerging technologies, acceptance, incentive strategies, and institutional-regulatory support. Sustainability 8 (4): 298.

Cardenas LM, Cuttle SP, Crabtree B, Hopkins A, Shepherd A, Scholefield D, Del Prado A, 2011. Cost effectiveness of nitrate leaching mitigation measures for grassland livestock systems at locations in England and Wales. Sci Total Environ 409: 1104-1115.

Cardinael R, Chevallier T, Barthes BG, Saby NPA, Parent T, Dupraz C, Bernoux M, Chenu C, 2015. Impact of alley cropping agroforestry on stocks, forms and spatial distribution of soil organic carbon-A case study in a Mediterranean context. Geoderma 259: 288-299.

Casals P, Baiges T, Bota G, Chocarro C, De Bello F, Fanlo R, Sebastià M, Taull M, 2009. Silvopastoral systems in the northeastern Iberian peninsula: A multifunctional perspective. In: Agroforestry in Europe; Rigueiro-Rodríguez A, McAdam J, Mosquera-Losada MR, pp: 161-181. Springer.

Cerro I, Antiguedad I, Srinavasan R, Sauvage S, Volk M, Sanchez-Perez JM, 2014. Simulating land management options to reduce nitrate pollution in an agricultural watershed dominated by an alluvial aquifer. J Environ Qual 43: 67-74.

Christen B, Dalgaard T, 2013. Buffers for biomass production in temperate European agriculture: A review and synthesis on function, ecosystem services and implementation. Biomass Bioenerg 55: 53-67.

Christensen JR, Nash MS, Neale A, 2013. Identifying riparian buffer effects on stream nitrogen in southeastern coastal plain watersheds. Environ Manage 52: 1161-1176.

Coello J, Piqué M, Vericat P, 2009. Guia pràctica - Producció de fusta de qualitat: plantacions de noguera i cirerer – Aproximació a les condicions catalanes. Centre de la Propietat Forestal, Generalitat de Catalunya. Santa Perpètua de Mogoda (Spain). 175 pp

Coello J, Pique M, Beltran M, Cervera T, Baiges T, 2017. Models de gestió per a plantacions forestals i agroforestals d'espècies productores de fusta de qualitat-Noguera híbrida (Juglans x intermedia), cirerer (Prunus avium L.), freixe de fulla gran (Fraxinus excelsior L.). Generalitat de Catalunya. Departament d'Agricultura, Ramaderia, Pesca i Alimentació-Centre de la Propietat Forestal. Santa Perpètua de Mogoda. 60 pp.

Coello J, Urbán I, Mosquera-Losada MR, 2018. Los sistemas silvoarables modernos en España. Cuad Soc Esp Cienc For 44 (2): 19-38.

Colomb V, 2009. Potential for agroforestry alley-cropping with valuable broadleaves in Central Catalonia. Master thesis. Univ. De Lleida, Spain.

Conesa J, 2007. Mapa geológica de Cataluña 1:50 000 con reagrupación de clases litológicas. Original map from the ICC (2006).

COSE, 2015. Madera con destino de sierra. [Sawwood]. Confederación de Organizaciones de Selvicultores de España. [In Spanish].

CWA, 2016. Els nitrats a l'aigua subterrània. Noves solucions per a un problema pendent. [Nitrates in groundwater. New solutions to outstanding problems]. In: Els nitrats a les aigües subterrànies a Catalunya, Jornada técnica projecte Life+InSiTrade, Barcelona. April 7.

DARP, 2015. Prospective studies in agricultural and food. Dept. Agriculture Livestock, Fisheries and Food of Catalonia.

DARPA, 2017. Informe anual del sector porcì. Dept. d'Agricultura, Ramaderia, Pesca i Alimentació-Generalitat de Catalunya. Ed. Universitat de Lleida.

De Benedictis M, Cosentino V, 1979. Economia dell'azienda agraria: teoria e metodi. Il mulino, Italia. 792 pp.

Den Herder M, Moreno G, Mosquera-Losada RM, Palma JHN, Sidiropoulou A, Freijanes JJS, Crous-Duran J, Paulo JA, Tome M, Pantera A, Papanastasis VP, Mantzanas K, Pachana P, Papadopoulos A, Plieninger T, Burgess PJ, 2017. Current extent and stratification of agroforestry in the European Union. Agr Ecosyst Environ 241: 121-132.

Dougherty MC, Thevathasan NV, Gordon AM, Lee H, Kort J, 2009. Nitrate and Escherichia coli NAR analysis in tile drain effluent from a mixed tree intercrop and monocrop system. Agr Ecosyst Environ 131: 77-84.

Dupraz C, Burgess P, Gavaland A, Graves A, Herzog F, Incoll L, Jackson N, Keesman K, Lawson G, Lecomte I, 2005. Synthesis of the silvoarable agroforestry for Europe project. INRA-UMR Syst. Ed., Montpellier. 254 pp.

EC, 2013. Report from the commission to the council and the European Parliament on the implementation of Council Directive 91/676/EEC concerning the protection of waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural sources based on Member State reports for the period 2008-2011. European Commission, Brussels.

Eichhorn MP, Paris P, Herzog F, Incoll LD, Liagre F, Mantzanas K, Mayus M, Moreno G, Papanastasis VP, Pilbeam DJ, Pisanelli A, Dupraz C, 2006. Silvoarable systems in europe-past, present and future prospects. Agroforest Syst 67: 29-50.

Faasch RJ, Patenaude G, 2012. The economics of short rotation coppice in Germany. Biomass Bioenerg 45: 27-40.

FAO, 2013. Forests for food security and nutrition. Conclusions by the Secretariat of the Int. Conf. Forests for Food Security and Nutrition. Rovaniemi (Lapland), 9-13 December.

Food & Water Europe, 2017. Spain, towards a pig factory farm nation?

Gasol CM, Brun F, Mosso A, Rieradevall J, Gabarrell X, 2010. Economic assessment and comparison of acacia energy crop with annual traditional crops in Southern Europe. Energ Policy 38: 592-597.

Giles J, 2005. Nitrogen study fertilizes fears of pollution. Nature 433: 791-791.

GOC, 2013. Estadístiques ramaderes, Censos de bestiar porcí. [Statistics cattle, pigs census]. Government of Catalonia.

GOC, 2015a. Evolució preus mitjans de la terra agrícola a Catalunya, 1997-2013. [Evolution of average prices of agricultural land in Catalonia, 1997-2013]. Government of Catalonia.

GOC, 2015b. Informe sobre el canal segarra-garrigues. [Report on the Segarra-Garrigues canal]. Government of Catalonia.

Graves AR, Burgess PJ, Palma JHN, Herzog F, Moreno G, Bertomeu M, Dupraz C, Liagre F, Keesman K, Van Der Werf W, et al., 2007. Development and application of bio-economic modelling to compare silvoarable, arable, and forestry systems in three European countries. Ecol Eng 29: 434-449.

Graves A, Burgess P, Liagre F, Dupraz C, 2017a. Farmer perception of benefits, constraints and opportunities for silvoarable systems: Preliminary insights from Bedfordshire, England. Outlook Agr 46: 74-83.

Graves AR, Burgess PJ, Liagre F, Dupraz C, 2017b. Farmer perception of benefits, constraints and opportunities for silvoarable systems: Preliminary insights from Bedfordshire, England. Outlook Agr 46: 74-83.

Grignani C, Acutis M, Zavattaro L, Bechini L, Bertora C, Gallina PM, Sacco D, 2009. Connecting different scales of nitrogen use in agriculture. XVI Nitrogen Workshop, Turin (Italy), June 28–July 1. pp: 329-330.

Gutierrez AS, Eras JJC, Billen P, Vandecasteele C, 2016. Environmental assessment of pig production in Cienfuegos, Cuba: Alternatives for manure management. J Clean Prod 112: 2518-2528.

Hauk S, Knoke T, Wittkopf S, 2014. Economic evaluation of short rotation coppice systems for energy from biomass-A review. Renew Sust Energ Rev 29: 435-448.

Herzog F, 1998. Streuobst: A traditional agroforestry system as a model for agroforestry development in temperate Europe. Agroforest Syst 42: 61-80.

INE, 2009. Agricultura y ganadería en España y Europa-Censo agrario. Instituto Nacional de Estadística, Gobierno de España.

Lawniczak AE, Zbierska J, Nowak B, Achtenberg K, Grzeskowiak A, Kanas K, 2016. Impact of agriculture and land use on nitrate contamination in groundwater and running waters in central-west Poland. Environ Monit Assess 188: 17.

Leach KA, Allingham KD, Conway JS, Goulding KWT, Hatch DJ, 2004. Nitrogen management for profitable farming with minimal environmental impact: The challenge for mixed farms in the Cotswold Hills, England. Int J Agr Sustain 2: 21-32.

Liagre F, Dupraz C, 2008. Agroforesterie: des arbres et des cultures. Ed. France Agricole. 413 pp.

MAGRAMA, 2015. Informe semanal de coyuntura. [Weekly Situation Report]. Subdireccion General de Estadísticas.

MAGRAMA, 2016. Machinery costs analysis model.

MAPAMA, 2016. Indicadores económicos carne de cerdo 2016. Ministerio de Agricultura y Pesca, Alimentación y Medio Ambiente, Gobierno de España.

Marquez EG, 2014. Análisis de precios, tendencia e información de los productos forestales. [Price analysis, trend and information of forest products]. RedFor.

Martinelli GDC, Schlindwein MM, Padovan MP, Gimenes RMT, 2019. Decreasing uncertainties and reversing paradigms on the economic performance of agroforestry systems in Brazil. Land Use Policy 80: 274-286.

Miguel GS, Corona B, Ruiz D, Landholm D, Laina R, Tolosana E, Sixto H, Canellas I, 2015. Environmental, energy and economic analysis of a biomass supply chain based on a poplar short rotation coppice in Spain. J Clean Prod 94: 93-101.

Mosquera-Losada MR, Mcadam JH, Romero-Franco R, Santiago-Freijanes JJ, Rigueiro-Rodróguez A, 2009. Definitions and components of agroforestry practices in Europe. In: Agroforestry in Europe; Rigueiro-Rodróguez A et al., pp: 3-19. Springer.

Mosquera-Losada MR, Ferreiro-Dominguez N, Daboussi S, Rigueiro-Rodriguez A, 2016. Sewage sludge stabilisation and fertiliser value in a silvopastoral system developed with Eucalyptus nitens Maiden in Lugo (Spain). Sci Total Environ 566: 806-815.

Mosquera-Losada M, Santiago Freijanes J, Pisanelli A, Rois M, Smith J, Den Herder M, Moreno G, Lamersdorf N, Ferreiro Domínguez N, Balaguer F, 2017. Deliverable 8.24: How can policy support the appropriate development and uptake of agroforestry in Europe?, 7 Sept. 21 pp.

Mosquera-Losada MR, Moreno G, Santiago-Freijanes JJ Ferreiro-Domínguez N, 2015. Sistemas Agroforestales y PAC. Ambienta 112: 110-124.

Nair VD, Nair PKR, Kalmbacher RS, Ezenwa IV, 2007. Reducing nutrient loss from farms through silvopastoral practices in coarse-textured soils of Florida, USA. Ecol Eng 29: 192-199.

Oenema O, Witzke HP, Klimont Z, Lesschen JP, Velthof GL, 2009. Integrated assessment of promising measures to decrease nitrogen losses from agriculture in EU-27. Agr Ecosyst Environ 133: 280-288.

Oenema O, 2012. Economic cost of nitrogen management. 17th Nitrogen Workshop -Innovations for sustainable use of nitrogen resources, Wexford (Ireland), June 26-29. pp: 262-263.

Pacheco FAL, Fernandes LFS, 2016. Environmental land use conflicts in catchments: A major cause of amplified nitrate in river water. Sci Total Environ 548: 173-188.

Palma JHN, 2006. Integrated assessment of silvoarable agroforestry at landscape scale. Doctoral thesis. Univ. of Wageningen University & Research, Wageningen, Netherlands.

Palma JHN, Graves AR, Bunce RGH, Burgess PJ, De Filippi R, Keesman KJ, Van Keulen H, Liagre F, Mayus M, Moreno G, Reisner Y, Herzog F, 2007. Modeling environmental benefits of silvoarable agroforestry in Europe. Agr Ecosyst Environ 119: 320-334.

Palma JHN, Paulo JA, Faias SP, Garcia-Gonzalo J, Borges JG, Tome M, 2015. Adaptive management and debarking schedule optimization of Quercus suber L. stands under climate change: case study in Chamusca, Portugal. Reg Environ Change 15: 1569-1580.

Pannell DJ, 1999. Social and economic challenges in the development of complex farming systems. Agroforestry Syst 45: 393-409.

Paolotti L, Boggia A, Castellini C, Rocchi L, Rosati A, 2016. Combining livestock and tree crops to improve sustainability in agriculture: a case study using the life cycle assessment (LCA) approach. J Clean Prod 131: 351-363.

Paris P, Briel J, Burkart K, Burgess P, Herzog F, Incoll L, Ispikoudis I, Liagre F, Mantzanas K, Mayus M, 2002. Extant silvoarable practices in Europe. Report of SAFE project, Italy, 83 pp.

Prapaspongsa T, Christensen P, Schmidt JH, Thrane M, 2010. LCA of comprehensive pig manure management incorporating integrated technology systems. J Clean Prod 18: 1413-1422.

Rancane S, Makovskis K, Lazdina D, Daugaviete M, Gutmane I, Berzins P, 2014. Analysis of economical, social and environmental aspects of agroforestry systems of trees and perennial herbaceous plants. Agron Res 12: 589-602.

Renwick A, Jansson T, Verburg PH, Revoredo-Giha C, Britz W, Gocht A, Mccracken D, 2013. Policy reform and agricultural land abandonment in the EU. Land Use Policy 30: 446-457.

Rigueiro-Rodríguez A, Mcadam J, Mosquera-Losada MR, 2008. Agroforestry in Europe: current status and future prospects, Springer Science & Business Media. 450 pp.

Rois-Díaz M, Lovric N, Lovric M, Ferreiro-Domínguez N, Mosquera-Losada MR, Den Herder M, Graves A, Palma JHN, Paulo JA, Pisanelli A, et al., 2017. Farmers' reasoning behind the uptake of agroforestry practices: evidence from multiple case-studies across Europe. Agrofor Syst 92: 811-828.

Sereke F, 2012. Transdisciplinary development of agroforestry systems. Doctoral Thesis. Univ. of Hohenheim, France.

Sereke F, Graves A.R, Dux D, Palma JHN, Herzog F, 2015. Innovative agroecosystem goods and services: key profitability drivers in Swiss agroforestry. Agron Sustain Dev 35: 759-770.

Sereke F, Dobricki M, Wilkes J, Kaeser A, Graves AR, Szerencsits E, Herzog F, 2016. Swiss farmers don't adopt agroforestry because they fear for their reputation. Agroforest Syst 90: 385-394.

Sevigne E, Gasol CM, Brun F, Rovira L, Pages JM, Camps F, Rieradevall J, Gabarrell X, 2011. Water and energy consumption of Populus spp. bioenergy systems: A case study in Southern Europe. Renew Sust Energ Rev 15: 1133-1140.

Sgroi F, Di Trapani AM, Fodera M, Testa R, Tudisca S, 2015. Economic assessment of Eucalyptus (spp.) for biomass production as alternative crop in Southern Italy. Renew Sust Energ Rev 44: 614-619.

Sierra-Pérez J, García-Pérez S, Blanc S, Boschmonart-Rives J, Gabarrell X, 2018. The use of forest-based materials for the efficient energy of cities: Environmental and economic implications of cork as insulation material. Sustain Cities Soc 37: 628-636.

Smith J, Pearce BD, Wolfe MS, 2013. Reconciling productivity with protection of the environment: Is temperate agroforestry the answer? Renew Agr Food Syst 28: 80-92.

Testa R., Di Trapani AM, Fodera M, Sgroi F, Tudisca S, 2014. Economic evaluation of introduction of poplar as biomass crop in Italy. Renew Sust Energ Rev 38: 775-780.

Torralba M, Fagerholm N, Burgess PJ, Moreno G, Plieninger T, 2016. Do European agroforestry systems enhance biodiversity and ecosystem services? A meta-analysis. Agr Ecosyst Environ 230: 150-161.

Valdivia C, Barbieri C, Gold MA, 2012. Between forestry and farming: Policy and environmental implications of the barriers to agroforestry adoption. Can J Agr Econ 60: 155-175.

Van Der Straeten B, Buysse J, Nolte S, Lauwers L, Claeys D, Van Huylenbroeck G, 2012. The effect of EU derogation strategies on the compliance costs of the nitrate directive. Sci Total Environ 421: 94-101.

Velthof GL, Lesschen JP, Webb J, Pietrzak S, Miatkowski Z, Pinto M, Kros J, Oenema O, 2014. The impact of the nitrates Directive on nitrogen emissions from agriculture in the EU-27 during 2000-2008. Sci Total Environ 468: 1225-1233.

Vilamanya JL, 2014. Avaluació dels costos de producció de cultius extensius en secà i regadiu. Dossier Tècnic. "Costos en l'agricultura" Núm 69, Generalitat de Catalunya.

Vilamanya JL, Piqué MAC, 2015. Costes de producción de cultivos extensivos en secano y regadío. Vida Rural 401: 38-47.

Zamora DS, Jose S, Napolitano K, 2009. Competition for N-15 labeled nitrogen in a loblolly pine-cotton alley cropping system in the southeastern United States. Agr Ecosyst Environ 131: 40-50.

Zavattaro L, Grignani C, Acutis M, Rochette P, 2012. Mitigation of environmental impacts of nitrogen use in agriculture Preface. Agr Ecosyst Environ 147: 1-3.

How to Cite
Blanc, S., Gasol, C. M., Martínez-Blanco, J., Muñoz, P., Coello, J., Casals, P., Mosso, A., & Brun, F. (2019). Economic profitability of agroforestry in nitrate vulnerable zones in Catalonia (NE Spain). Spanish Journal of Agricultural Research, 17(1), e0101.
Agricultural economics